The Eyes Are the Best Part
- Barnes & Noble 2 – Barnes & Noble's Best Horror Books of 2024
- Elle – The Best Mystery and Thriller Books of 2024
- Goodreads 2 – Readers' Favorite Horror
- Indigo 2 – Best Horror of 2024
- Paste – The Best Horror Books of 2024
- Time – The 100 Must-Read Books of 2024
- Vulture – The Best Horror Books of 2024 (So Far)