Martyr!
- Amazon – Best Books of 2024
- Amazon – Best Literature and Fiction of 2024
- Barnes & Noble – Barnes & Noble's Best Fiction of 2024
- BookRiot – Best Books Of 2024
- BookRiot – Best Books Of 2024
- Bookshop Santa Cruz – Best Literary Fiction & Poetry of the Year
- Chicago Public Library – Top 10 Books of 2024
- Debutiful – The Best Debut Books of 2024
- Electric Lit – Electric Lit’s Best Novels of 2024
- Electric Lit – Electric Lit’s Best Novels of 2024
- Goodreads – Readers' Favorite Fiction
- Hyperallergic – The 30 Best Art Books of 2024
- Indigo – Best Literary Fiction of 2024
- Indigo – Top 100 Best Books of 2024
- Los Angeles Times – The 15 best books of 2024, reissues included
- NPR – Books We Love 2024
- NPR – Books We Love 2024
- NYPL – Best Books for Adults 2024
- NYPL – Best Books for Adults 2024
- New York Times – 100 Notable Books of 2024
- New York Times – 100 Notable Books of 2024
- STLPR – Best books of 2024, chosen by St. Louis librarians
- STLPR – Best books of 2024, chosen by St. Louis librarians
- Slate – The 10 Best Books of 2024
- TIME – The 10 Best Fiction Books of 2024
- The Atlantic – The books that made us think the most this year
- The Globe – The Globe 100: The best books of 2024
- The Globe – The Globe 100: The best books of 2024
- The New Yorker – The Best Books of 2024
- The New Yorker – The Best Books of 2024
- The Skinny – The Skinny's Books of 2024
- Time – The 100 Must-Read Books of 2024
- Vanity Fair – 21 Best Books of 2024
- Vulture – The Best Books of 2024
- Vulture – The Best Books of 2024
- Washington Post – 50 Notable Works of Fiction from 2024
- Waterstones – The Best Fiction Books of 2024